FightCPS does not advocate or condone violence or illiegal activities of any kind.
FightCPS is intended to help people learn enough about the law to be able to successfully defend themselves and their families against false accusations using legal documents and strategies that put parents in a stronger position when they go back to court.
For more information, see the FAQ.
Child Protective Services, CPS, has devastated and destroyed hundreds of thousands of families in America during the last thirty years leaving a trail of broken hearts, broken dreams, and shattered childhoods.
Rather than helping families, government agents have used unconstitutional laws in Juvenile Court to rip children away from their loving parents, break asunder God-given, natural, parent-child bonds, and adopt the children of the grieving out to others who profit financially with large monthly adoption subsidy payments.
Child Protective Services must be stopped! The law that started this, CAPTA, must be repealed. We must work tirelessly to inform the public of this very dangerous travesty of justice. We must keep faith knowing that if there is a God, there is an answer and a way to end this heartache.
Child Protective Services Agents - please come to your senses! Family destruction on false or trivial grounds is wrong, reprehensible, and inhumane.
Fosterers - be aware that for the money you get you are holding much-loved children away from their grieving families while the parents are forced to perform a service plan that is anything but a service to them. I call this hostage holding for the government. This is not kindness - to help misguided government agents destroy family relationships and break loving bonds.
CPS workers and fosterers - I ask that you now let the children of the innocent return to their homes where they are truly valued, adored, and loved by the parents God gave them.
Family rights are God-given rights. And they should not be ignored or postponed. Every moment these loving parents and children spend separated from one another is a torment beyond what anyone should ever have to bear.
It is unworthy of human dignity to allow this terrorism and torture of families to go on without saying something, speaking out, and trying to make a change.
Site mission: To provide information and support for families attacked by Child Protective Services and child welfare agents, especially those families facing false or trivial accusations of child abuse or neglect; and for researchers working to protect natural family rights.
|
Fighting Child Protective Services False Accusations
July 6, 2007
Children are better off when left in troubled homes, and not detained in state custody foster homes.
Joseph Doyle Jr., an economics professor at the MIT Sloan School of Management did a study on foster children compared to children living in troubled homes, funded by the National Science Foundation. He used the analytic tools of applied economics to discover that “…children on the margin of foster care placement have better employment, delinquency, and teen motherhood outcomes when they remain at home.”
PLEASE, social workers, legislators, everyone. LISTEN. Most kids are better off when left in their natural family homes. If you care about children, if you want them to have good lives and turn out to be happy, productive citizens, don’t take them away from non-abusive parents.
Doyle’s study tracked more than 15,000 children in Illinois from 1990 to 2002. He chose Illinois because they provided the statistics he needed. He screened out extreme cases of abuse and concentrated only on children whose cases could have gone either way (remaining in their family homes, or going to foster homes).
A July 3, 2007 USA Today article by Wendy Koch states, “Studies . . . show that the 500,000 children in U.S. foster care are more likely than other kids to drop out of school, commit crimes, abuse drugs and become teen parents. . . . His research has shown that this holds true even when foster kids are compared with other disadvantaged youth.”
In conclusion, Doyle wrote: “With the child welfare system affecting so many children who appear to be at high risk of poor life outcomes, it would be useful to know whether abused children benefit from being removed from their families. The analysis here uses the effective randomization of abuse investigators, who differ somewhat in their tendency to have children placed in foster care, to estimate causal effects of placement on longer-term outcomes. Children assigned to investigators with higher removal rates are more likely to be placed in foster care themselves, and they are found to have higher delinquency rates, along with some evidence of higher teen birth rates and lower earnings.”
Thank you, Joseph Doyle Jr., for doing this study.
Sources:
Joseph Doyle Jr. - click on his research link and you’ll see a link to the paper he wrote about his study.
Kids Gain More From Family Than Foster Care - from the MIT News Office
Study: Troubled homes better than foster care - by Wendy Koch, for USA Today
Filed under: CPS — Linda @ 7:46 am
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Privacy Policy - please read before posting anything to this site. (Link opens in another window or tab.)
Copyright Notice: According to US Copyright law, copyright vests initially in the author(s) of the work. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, any copyrighted material herein is distributed without profit or payment to those who have an interest in receiving this information for non-profit research and educational purposes only. For more information go to: Title 17, Sec.107. If you are the copyright holder and choose to have your work removed from this website, email the webmaster and it will be done. However we here at fightcps.com hope you prefer that our researchers continue to benefit from access to your work.
Broken Links: Because many old news articles are taken offline you will find broken links in the archives of this weblog. There's nothing we can do to prevent this problem.
|
I am a california teacher, and I saw first hand the tragedy of the CPS system. A beautiful 2 year old boy at the preschool I worked at, was with a foster care couple who wanted to adopt him. They were upper middle class, and loved him more than anything. CPS suddenly removed him from their home, placed him w/ a foster care family in a mobile home who were obviously trash, and he was beaten to death by them. It makes me sick, and I think of that boy when situations arise when I may need to call CPS for supposed help.
Comment by Bitter Teacher — July 6, 2007 @ 8:40 pm
Hopefully people like you and I and the rest of us working so hard to end the systematic abuse of innocent children are making headway! The public is becoming more aware and hopefully will stop using child protective services as a tool to hurt the adult, and also hopefully more and more people are seeing that children are far better left at home unless of course in cases of true abuse! I feel only a jury should be able to decide what is and what isn’t true abuse..
Louise
Comment by Louise — July 7, 2007 @ 9:52 am
Good article. It is definitely true. My cousins were in the system when I was little. One of my cousins has serious burn scars from being abused in the foster home. She doesn’t talk about it. My aunt won them back, thankfully. I don’t think that they would have the life they had now, if they were still in their abusive foster home.
Comment by startingover — July 7, 2007 @ 2:31 pm
Oh, same for my children. They will definately not be the same. Well, that has already started.
Comment by startingover — July 7, 2007 @ 2:32 pm
Amazing WONDERFUL STRONG Report that I am going to add to my copy of things to submit to this court house in WV.
Good research . Thank GOD for your sight for awareness and knowledge..
Comment by Angela Hawk — July 7, 2007 @ 10:36 pm
wow i thought that but now it is confirmed. i was thinking is it that horrible for a child to be in a messy home. not a dangerous home but messy, or for a parent to make a mistake in being a parent and they hound on it and remove the child. is that what is going on.
Comment by kwanie — July 9, 2007 @ 9:06 am
It is true and I believe this report because it confirms that our cousin was in foster care since he was 3 yrs old. He was in there until 21!!!
Look what happened to him? He committed crimes already as soon as he left the foster care home at age 21 for break and entering, and stealing money. He does not have a clue what to do because no one told him how to live his life and get a job. No one was there to educate him how to do life management. He was desperate, hungry, wanting money to buy food, and he went to food banks once a month. Stayed with us for a while but sadly he committed crimes and he was guilty in court and must pay retributions, about $500 to the victims he stole from, and stayed in jail for 30 days. His record is doomed because he was an Adult when he committed the crime. No one wants to hire him because of his “record”. He went back to his Mother that he had not seen much over the last 20 years. He had visits but it wasn’t much. He was a permanent crown ward in a foster care system. He succumbed to hard drugs and alcohol.
Really sad, sad because his life is going nowhere. This is what Foster Care taught him.
Comment by Frustrated — July 10, 2007 @ 6:32 am
validation at last. My family was in the system for abusive boyfriend/father. He put me in wheelchair, destroyed house, and molested his children. Cps says it was my fault that house was destroyed, and demanded i clean it from chair. Kids went to grandparents, with alcoholic grandfather rather then stay with messy, disabled mom.
p.s. they refuse to charge him with molestation as he is “mentally ill’.
Comment by bj davis — July 10, 2007 @ 9:29 am
During the 15 months my 16 year old step daughter was in my sole care, (along with 2 other kids) it was rough at times, and a lot of hurtful things were said and done.
She “decided” (along with her sister) that life beyond my home was bigger, brighter, more fun, less strict, etc,etc,etc. Both of these girls had the belief that if they could make enough allegations (which they did), CPS would remove them (which they did along with my biological son).
The older one was the luckier as she ended up being placed with her boyfriend’s parents, and she basically gets whatever she wants, so good for her.
The 16 year old has, since November been discharged from private residence foster care and FIVE group homes. She has been admitted to the psych ward twice, has been forced to change schools three times, acts out to the extent that she hardly ever has any privileges except going to school and staying in doors.
Three weeks ago, she was arrested and charged with assualt and battery. Her biological Father refuses to allow her to live with him, and her Mother has voluntarily relinquished her own parental rights. Of course, she never figured ANY of this would happen, but that she would stay in the home of school friends and do what she wanted.
I have raised this child since she was 14 months old. I agreed to be sole custodian after her mother abandoned us all for men and drugs.
Despite the lies, the real hurt and pain this kid has caused, I cannot help but love her, and yet I also will likley never see or even speak to her until she ages out of the system in 2 more years.
I cannot see her being adopted at her age and with her track record. I hope I am wrong. I hope things will change for her and that she won’t spend two of the most crucial years of her life continuing to bounce from group home to jail to group home.
But in all reality, even if I were allowed to, I could not let her return to the home I have provided for her 13 years. When she made a false allegation of sexual abuse three years ago, my therapist who has worked with men released from prison for REAL sex crimes, (not the reason I was seeing him) told me flat out, he has seen men go to jail for less, and that if I allowed her THEN back into the home, she would make further allegations. He was right and I was wrong. Sadly, her parents are wrong too. But I have no control over that.
Once, I was able to really reach this kid unlike anyone else. She shoplifted several times, and I got all the merchandise and we rode all over town returning it and with her confessing to each store manager what she had done. Twice, she stole my credit card and made purchases without my knowledge or permission. I took her to the Juvenile authorities who read her the riot act, and she seemed to straighten up after that. This past year, I encouraged her to attend the auditions for a school play. She won the lead role, and this with NO prior drama experience. She started dating, and I did my best to try to help her navigate, but it was tough, since i was always reluctant to even speak about certain issues between young men and young women because of the allegations she had made. Funny, though, that even AFTER she made them the first time, and they were investigated and totally dismissed by DSS, they found me not only fit enough to have kinship guardian care over her, they practically threatened me if I did not do so. Yes, I was very wary being a single step father living with two teenage girls who both had “histories”. The oldest was expelled fropm school 4 years ago for alleging falsely that a male teacher had touched her inappropiatley. The poor man was placed on adminstrative leave, investigated out the wazoo, his name ruined, and I think he even took a polygraph. My step daughter was expelled for “assault”, which I imagine is the only indiscretion the school code would allow.
Because of these two girls, I was subjected to four months of a criminal investigation during which time my ex wife, my older children from that marriage, past employers, even nieces and nephews were all asked unbelievable things about me. I volunteered myself to be interrogated, without benefit of an attorney, and after 5 grueling hours, the Detective helped me draft a statment and in the end, BOTH step daughters were charged with felony sexual abuse (which they confessed to) for events which took place with my biological son a few years back. The DA dropped all charges, however and NOTHING was uncovered reagrding me, not even a parking violation.
I am starting to ramble….all this will be over soon, as after 9 months, we will finally have a hearing. My 13 year old son,. who is the real victim in all of this, was initially removed, placed in an unlicensed foster home with a convicted felon, and of course, was very emotionally abused. After 5 months, I was finally able to prevail upon my court appointed attorney to file a Motion to have my son removed not only from his abusive foster setting, but totally out of this county. in so doing, I knew that even the two hours a week I did get would be further diminished, and it has been. But, he is safe and with REAL family, living with one of my older sons and his wife. He knows I fought for him, that I believed him when he told the truth about his sisters, and when he made his case worker promise “not to tell until he was gone”, I believed him when he spoke about the abuse of his foster setting. They told him .I should “burn in hell for what I had done” and that “DSS is filling your head full of false hope, you will NEVER go home. They made him listen to a tape supposedly of “all the souls in Hell screaming in agony for their sins” and made him get on his knees in front of them and pray that God would forgive him and not send him to Hell.
The case worker promised my son he would never have to go back. He remained there 3 more months before I could get him away. My son knows I fought for him, but this has all been so much on him, and 9 months is an eternity to a kid, and well, I know he loves me, but he has “bonded” (who wouldnt after what he went through) with the array of brothers, uncles, cousins and grandparents my side of the family affords him. I told him he “wasn’t a foster kid anymore” and he beamed…..
The trauma kids go through by being ripped away from everything they know, whether it is good or not so good, and being plopped amidst total starngers, not being told anything, not being able to see their Mom or Dad, the hours and hours spent silently sobbing, hoping no one else in this strange place will hear, having no one familiar, not knowing when or if they will ever go “home” just literally kills something in children. Even under optimal conditions (unless there truly was horrific abuse), no one knows how much suffering these children endure, how vulnerable it makes them, how pliable—until that thing, whatever it is, hope or caring or whatever—whithers and you can see it in their eyes during visits. Those of you who have been through this know exacty what I mean.
Nothing in your life or theirs will ever be the same again.
God bless all the hurting parents, and God protect all the children, the light fading from their eyes a little dimmer each passing day. Amen.
Comment by Ken Ashworth — July 13, 2007 @ 8:30 pm
Very interesting, scholarly piece of economics research.
“Freakonomics “( economic research ) tying together what seems to be unrelated topics has been a NYT bestseller for over a year.
The fact that this study was commissioned is very heartening especially to folks like Mr. Ashworth above & the debacle which took place with his bio son.
We simply CANNOT AFFORD THESE FOSTER CARE DEBACLES ANY MORE.
These studies are not done cheaply, and interest in the topic indicates that realization about the trauma of FC is spreading.
Families will win their rights, slowly, since so many people feed off FC and related CPS non-issues.
This struggle is certainly similar to the struggle for civil rights in the US which took around 100 years.
With Internet exposure and folks like Len, Linda, Suzanne, Cheryl, etc., hopefully we are approaching the end of this tragedy for blameless families.
Comment by Fern — July 15, 2007 @ 7:00 am
CPS took my 10 year old because I had a bad/adverse reaction to anti-depressants. They felt he was in harm because I could not wake up. My attorney thinks this case is ridiculous, but meanwhile my son is in a foster home and very confused. CPS does not have a clue!
Comment by Kim — March 26, 2009 @ 6:56 am
Kim, I agree with your attorney - a ten year old would not be in danger, though he might be frightened. That’s old enough to get a neighbor or relative to help revive you. This is one of those cases where the child is being harmed by separation from you. I hope you can get him released from foster incarceration soon.
Comment by LindaJoMartin — March 26, 2009 @ 7:40 pm
Don’t forget who is behind it all it these Judges who makes these decisions these Judges are stupid to believe DHS lies and county attorney and attorney general is DHS laywers they are the crooked ones everybody should write to NBC dateline
Comment by Terri Rote — August 13, 2009 @ 11:38 am
I to have seen cps remove children wrongly but i was one of the lucky ones i had made a arrangment with the courts that i would no longer contact my kids if my brother could adopt my 2 children this was a 2 1/2 yr fight all because i am a prop 215 user and supporter.
Comment by Antoinette — August 21, 2009 @ 4:11 pm
There adoption was final on nov 12,2009 ihave not seen my children since2006 march. i am at peace knowing there with family and one day we will be together. My suggestion is that anyone who loses there kids to cps contact family and friends with no criminal recored and see if they can foster your child. my GOD be with all the families hurting to nite because of cps.
Comment by Antoinette — August 21, 2009 @ 4:16 pm
I was very lucky and my daughter was sent to a foster family that was nothing like we know of. I actually keep a close contact with them and they help my family out. I let them adopt my youngest son since my social worker said he was going to be removed from me sine I had an on going case.
My case was based fully on “he said she said”. CPS placed my son with his father and grandmother who is abusive. I had the proof also but it was 2 years old and no use. Honestly if CPS had a brain they would know that people need help to get over mental disorders and what not. Isnt that what the use against us? Oh they arent mentally stable they need therapy right? Well when someone says they have a gun and want to shoot themselves or say they are mentally unstable thats a red flag and should be investigated even if its 2 years old. You dont get over that on your own in my opinon. Pretty backwards dont you think?
I ask the father for pictures and get nothing. I havent seen my son in almost a year and when my brother asked him where mommy was he said I DONT KNOW. That hurts. The father just refuses to let me see him and my social worker is ok with it.
Comment by Karina — September 16, 2009 @ 1:41 pm
My grand daughters have been in foster care for a year and a half now. The oldest one has been trying to tell the caseworkers and fosterparents that she doesn’t want to be there. She wants to be with her mother. When we met with the caseworkers a few months ago they told us they were thinking of bringing the girls to my house since they believed it to be a stable home where the girls could live till mom could find a place of her own to live with the girls. I have since been convinced that these were lies to give us a false sense of hope. None of us have seen the girls in over two months. My daughter was told that the reason was transportation issues. They didn’t want to have to transport the girls to my house to visit which is where my daughter has been living. The three girls were together in the same home but have since been separated, the oldest in a different home than her younger sisters. I think it is criminal what they have done to these girls and to our family!!! All because of one spanking that the oldest one got for mouthing off to her mom.
What do we do? How can we get these girls out of this EVIL system?
We need help!!!
Comment by LeAnn — October 20, 2009 @ 10:26 am